Case from Practice Tax adviser · Funds

Purchase price allocation: too little building, too little depreciation

The cases are based on typical constellations from practice. They are anonymised, generalised and narratively condensed; persons, places and figures have been changed.

Key answer. Only the building is depreciated. The BMF working aid for purchase price allocation has no binding effect for the parties and the tax court (BFH, judgment of 21 July 2020, IX R 26/19). An appraisal can substantiate the allocation by actual market values. Legal basis: BFH IX R 26/19 of 21 July 2020. As of 13 October 2026, revised 21 November 2026.

The purchase contract was signed, the joy brief. Then came the allocation of the purchase price between land and building, and with it the question of how much can be depreciated at all.

Only the building is depreciated, not the land. The higher the land share, the smaller the depreciation base. In sought-after locations the tax office's calculation often sets the land high, and the building share shrinks.

The tax office frequently resorts to the working aid of the Federal Ministry of Finance. The Federal Fiscal Court has held that this working aid has no binding effect for the parties and the tax court, judgment of 21 July 2020, IX R 26/19. It is a standardising tool, not the last word.

So we determined the shares of land and building by their actual market values, under a recognised method. Where the working aid sets the land too high, an appraisal can substantiate the appropriate allocation.

Whether the tax office follows the allocation depends on whether the appraisal carries the market values. The effort is not worthwhile in every case; that can be clarified in advance on a rough basis.

Case facts

Occasion
Purchase price allocation land and building, depreciation base
Asset
Let condominium in an apartment building
Method
Allocation by actual market values, recognised method
Legal basis
BFH IX R 26/19 of 21 July 2020; BMF working aid for purchase price allocation

When to involve us

Roles and responsibilities. TWGA handles the mandate and prepares the allocation appraisal. The entry in the tax return and the tax assessment remain with the tax adviser.

Legal basis

  • Federal Fiscal Court, judgment of 21 July 2020, IX R 26/19, on the lack of binding effect of the BMF working aid
  • BMF working aid for the allocation of a total purchase price (Federal Ministry of Finance)
  • German version of this case

Anonymised and generalised practice example. No tax or legal advice, no guarantee of outcome in the individual case.

← Back to Cases from Practice