Matrimonial gains: two reference dates, one reliable value
The cases are based on typical constellations from practice. They are anonymised, generalised and narratively condensed; persons, places and figures have been changed.
Key answer. For the property two reference dates apply: the initial assets (§ 1374 BGB) and the final assets as at the date the divorce petition becomes pending (§ 1384 BGB). Valuation follows § 1376 BGB with the market value at the respective reference date. Legal basis: §§ 1374, 1376, 1384 BGB. As of 13 October 2026, revised 21 November 2026.
At the end of a marriage stood a house and the question of who is owed how much of it. Two people, one property, two points in time that are readily confused.
The equalisation of accrued gains (Zugewinnausgleich) compares initial and final assets. For the property that means two reference dates, not one. The initial assets follow § 1374 BGB, the final assets § 1384 BGB as at the date the divorce petition becomes pending.
Valuation follows § 1376 BGB. For a property that is the market value at the respective reference date, not the purchase price of back then and not the wish of today.
So we determined the market value as at the governing reference dates, under a recognised method, on the instruction of the court or the parties. A value that both sides and the court can follow takes some of the sharpness out of the dispute.
What follows from it in law is decided not by the valuation but by family law. Our task is the value, not the claim.
Case facts
- Occasion
- Equalisation of accrued gains, valuation of a property
- Asset
- Terraced house, formerly owner-occupied
- Method
- Market value under ImmoWertV as at the governing reference dates
- Reference dates
- Initial assets (§ 1374 BGB), final assets (§ 1384 BGB, pendency)
- Legal basis
- §§ 1374, 1376, 1384 BGB
When to involve us
- When a property must be valued in the equalisation of gains and both sides need a reliable value.
- When a court requires a neutral valuation as at specific reference dates.
- When, as a family lawyer, you need a verifiable basis for settlement or proceedings.
Legal basis
Anonymised and generalised practice example. No tax or legal advice, no guarantee of outcome in the individual case.
← Back to Cases from Practice