Inheritance: the tax office sets the value too high
The cases are based on typical constellations from practice. They are anonymised, generalised and narratively condensed; persons, places and figures have been changed.
Key answer. If the assessed value is too high, the taxpayer can prove a lower common value under § 198 BewG, with an appraisal under a recognised ImmoWertV method, with an on-site inspection and the date of death as reference date. Legal basis: § 198 BewG. As of 13 October 2026, revised 21 November 2026.
The heirs sat at a table that was too large. Three siblings, one house, four opinions. The tax office had already set the value, from tables, without ever having set foot in the house.
For inheritance tax, what counts is the common value (gemeiner Wert) of the property. The tax office derives it in the standardised procedure under the Valuation Act. That procedure does not know the individual house; it knows its key data.
So we looked at it. The roof from the year of construction, the pipes older than the youngest heir, a floor plan from a time when people still liked hallways.
§ 198 BewG permits proof of a lower common value, with an appraisal under a recognised method of the ImmoWertV, with an on-site inspection, as at the date of death as the valuation reference date.
Whether the tax office follows is decided not by hope but by whether the evidence holds. So we build it in a way that can be recalculated step by step.
Case facts
- Occasion
- Inheritance, assessment for inheritance tax
- Asset
- Single-family house
- Method
- Asset-value or income-value method under ImmoWertV, with on-site inspection
- Reference date
- Date of death
- Legal basis
- § 198 BewG, proof of the lower common value
When to involve us
- When an assessment or inheritance tax notice appears too high. An objection is generally subject to a one-month deadline.
- When a property falls into an estate or a gift and a reliable value is needed.
- When, as a tax adviser, estate administrator or inheritance lawyer, you need verifiable evidence for the tax office.
Legal basis
Anonymised and generalised practice example. No tax or legal advice, no guarantee of outcome in the individual case.
← Back to Cases from Practice